Shariah-Compliant Investing: A Guide for Financial Advisors

A practical guide to building and managing Shariah-compliant portfolios, from client intake and product selection to ongoing compliance monitoring.

Halal Investing for Financial Advisors

A client asks you for a Shariah-compliant portfolio. Finding stocks and funds that pass a Shariah screen is the easier part. The harder part is fitting the screens into a process that still handles diversification, taxes, cash and retirement accounts, and keeping the portfolio compliant as companies report.

Observance varies, so start with your client's own rules. A Shariah-compliant portfolio avoids riba (interest) and haram (prohibited) businesses, and each client's restrictions vary.

Fixed income and cash take the most planning, because few Shariah-compliant products exist. Clients may also want help with purification (giving to charity the share of income from prohibited sources) and zakat (an annual 2.5% charitable obligation on qualifying wealth).

Key takeaways

  • Before you invest, agree on the Shariah screening methodology you'll apply, the treatment of Questionable holdings, extra exclusions and the response to a non-compliant holding. Record them in the investment policy.
  • Screens test revenue sources and interest-bearing debt and cash. Methodologies set different limits, so a company can pass one and fail another.
  • A firm using only Shariah-certified funds relies on each fund's oversight. Screened stocks and direct indexing need screening data.
  • In Zoya's AAOIFI ratings on November 19, 2026, 54% of S&P 500 weight was Compliant, 20% Questionable and 26% Non-Compliant, with Compliant names concentrated in technology. Screening without adjusting weights concentrates a portfolio by sector and stock.
  • Zakat and purification are separate obligations, and your role can range from education to calculation.

Table of contents

  1. Understanding client requirements
  2. How Shariah screening works
  3. Choosing an implementation approach
  4. How Shariah screening reshapes the S&P 500
  5. Portfolio construction considerations
  6. Agreeing on a Shariah investment policy
  7. Monitoring and maintaining compliance
  8. Supporting clients with purification and zakat
  9. A worked case study
  10. How Zoya supports advisory firms
  11. Frequently asked questions

Understanding client requirements

Pew Research Center counts about 5.5 million Muslims in the US, and Statistics Canada counted about 1.8 million in Canada in 2021. Your clients may describe the goal as halal (permissible) investing.

Before you propose anything, ask three questions. Does the client follow a particular scholar or screening methodology? Should gray-area companies be included, excluded or decided case by case? Which sectors should you avoid beyond Shariah screening, such as fossil fuels? The policy checklist below covers the rest.

How Shariah screening works

A Shariah screen tests each company's business activities and its financial position. A holding you buy has to pass both. AAOIFI, the Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions, publishes a Shariah standard for screening, and Zoya's methodology follows it. Index providers such as MSCI, S&P, Dow Jones and FTSE Russell apply their own methodologies, which use similar tests with different thresholds and definitions.

The business screen

The business screen asks how a company earns its money. A company whose core business is haram fails, such as alcohol, gambling, pork, pornography or interest-based finance. Most screening methodologies allow impermissible income up to 5% of revenue.

Some businesses sit in a gray area where scholars differ, such as advertising platforms and supermarkets that sell alcohol. Zoya marks these Questionable and leaves the call to the investor, which in practice means you and your client. Questionable can also mean the company discloses too little to judge.

The financial screen

The financial screen caps a company's interest-bearing debt at about one-third of its size. It applies a similar cap to interest-bearing cash and securities. AAOIFI sets each limit at 30% of market value. MSCI and FTSE Russell use one-third of total assets. Under AAOIFI's Shariah Standard 21, these limits are an exception: borrowing or depositing at interest remains forbidden at any amount, and investors purify the related income.

A worked example

Take a hypothetical freight company, Company A.

Company A
Market value $10 billion
Total assets $6 billion
Interest-bearing debt $2.5 billion
Interest-bearing cash and securities $0.8 billion
Revenue $4 billion, including $80 million of interest from customer financing
  • Business screen: freight is permissible, and interest is 2% of revenue. Company A passes.
  • Market-value test: debt is 25% and interest-bearing cash is 8% of $10 billion, both under 30%. Company A passes.
  • Total-assets test: debt is 41.7% of total assets, above the one-third limit MSCI and FTSE Russell use. Company A fails.

So the same balance sheet passes AAOIFI's test and fails MSCI's and FTSE Russell's, because AAOIFI divides by market value and the others divide by total assets. Market value also changes over time. If the market value used in the calculation fell to $7 billion, Company A's debt would reach 35.7% of it, and Company A would fail the market-value test too, with the same balance sheet.

How the methodologies differ

MSCI figures for its Islamic Index Series from the December 2025 methodology. FTSE figures from FTSE Russell's Shariah index ground rules, February 2026.

Limit on AAOIFI as Zoya applies it MSCI Islamic Index Series FTSE Russell Shariah
Interest-bearing debt 30% of market value 30% of total assets to enter, 33.33% to stay 33.333% of total assets
Cash and interest-bearing securities Interest-bearing assets, 30% of market value 30% of total assets to enter, 33.33% to stay 33.333% of total assets
Receivables and cash - 46% of total assets to enter, 70% to stay 50% of total assets
Impermissible income, interest included 5% of revenue 5% of revenue 5% of revenue

Index providers give companies already in an index some room before removing them. At MSCI, a company whose debt or cash ratio rises above 33.33% stays in the index until the ratio has been over that limit for three quarterly reviews in a row. It must stay under 35%, and its average over four periods must stay under 33.33%. FTSE Russell keeps a company until its ratio has been outside a band of 31.667% to 35% for two quarters in a row. These buffers apply only to the financial ratios. The providers also define debt and cash differently and calculate the ratios differently, so the table shows only their main thresholds.

In our experience, most clients don't name a screening methodology or a Shariah standard. Be ready to explain the main methodologies, recommend one and apply it consistently. If a client does follow a scholar or methodology, use theirs. Providers can also rate the same stock differently, because they may use different financial data, update on different schedules or read gray-area businesses differently, as Zoya's help article explains.

Choosing an implementation approach

Most firms use one or more of five approaches, depending on the methodology you agree on, the account size and how much monitoring the firm can take on.

Approach Suits Operational load
Shariah-certified funds Clients comfortable with a fund's methodology Low: the fund screens and removes holdings
Screened individual stocks A specific methodology or a concentrated position High: checks before each trade and after each filing
Direct indexing from a benchmark Larger taxable accounts with extra exclusions Medium to high: data and monitoring
Third-party model or separately managed account Firms without in-house Shariah research Medium: diligence on the manager's methodology
In-house model portfolios Firms with many Shariah clients High: screening, monitoring and documentation

A firm that uses only Shariah-certified funds may not need a screening data subscription, because each fund's index provider or Shariah advisors decide what it holds. Data becomes useful once you pick stocks, run a direct-indexed sleeve or review what a client already owns.

A Shariah equity ETF covers only the equity part of a portfolio. Fixed income, cash, international exposure and existing holdings each need their own plan. Fixed income usually means sukuk (Islamic investment certificates that pay returns from underlying assets in place of interest).

Shariah-certified funds in the US

A selection, not a complete list; see our guides to the best halal ETFs and Amana mutual funds for more. The review column shows how often each fund's index is reviewed. UMMA's index is rebalanced quarterly, but the fund is actively managed. The Amana ETFs follow no index. Raqaba LLC is SP Funds' Shariah advisor and auditor; Wahed's prospectus names Shariyah Review Bureau as its funds' Shariah adviser. Expense ratios as of November 18, 2026, from issuers or SEC filings; Azzad's is net of fee waivers.

Ticker Fund Exposure Shariah adviser / index review Expense ratio
SPUS SP Funds S&P 500 Sharia Industry Exclusions ETF US large cap Raqaba LLC; monthly 0.45%
HLAL Wahed FTSE USA Shariah ETF US equity Shariyah Review Bureau; quarterly 0.50%
MNZL Manzil Russell Halal USA Broad Market ETF US broad market, with a human-rights exclusion screen Shariah Supervisory Board; quarterly 0.40%
SPWO SP Funds S&P World (ex-US) ETF Equity outside the US Raqaba LLC; monthly if needed 0.55%
UMMA Wahed Dow Jones Islamic World ETF International equity Shariyah Review Bureau; quarterly rebalance, annual reconstitution 0.65%
AMEI / AMGR / AMEM Amana Equity Income, Growth and Developing World ETFs Actively managed equity, launched mid-2026 Saturna's Shariah policies, reviewed by Amanie Advisors; no index 0.76% / 0.61% / 0.91%
SPRE SP Funds S&P Global REIT Sharia ETF Global REITs Raqaba LLC; monthly 0.50%
SPSK SP Funds Dow Jones Global Sukuk ETF Sukuk Raqaba LLC; monthly 0.50%
AMAPX / AMIPX Amana Participation Fund Sukuk mutual fund Fund's Shariah advisor 0.81% / 0.57%
WISEX Azzad Wise Capital Fund Shariah fixed income mutual fund Azzad's Shariah board 0.89%

Shariah funds in Canada

The Wealthsimple Shariah World Equity Index ETF, ticker WSHR, charges a 0.50% management fee and is the only Canadian-listed Shariah ETF at the time of writing. The Mackenzie Shariah Global Equity Fund, a mutual fund launched in 2024, has a Series F management expense ratio of 1.10%. Global Growth Assets offers the Global Iman Fund.

How Shariah screening reshapes the S&P 500

We assessed the S&P 500's constituents, as held by SPY, with Zoya's AAOIFI ratings to see how screening reshapes a portfolio. By weight, 54.2% of the index was Compliant, 20.0% Questionable and 25.8% Non-Compliant. By count, only 227 of 503 share lines were Compliant, about 45%, because the Compliant stocks are larger on average, led by Apple, Nvidia and Broadcom. Apple, Nvidia and Broadcom make up 30.7% of a cap-weighted Compliant-only portfolio, and its 10 largest companies make up 47.8%, against 38.8% for the index's 10 largest.

Sector S&P 500 weight Weight in a Compliant-only portfolio
Information Technology 35.5% 50.9%
Financials 12.6% 4.2%
Health Care 10.4% 15.1%
Consumer Discretionary 9.8% 7.3%
Communication Services 8.9% 0.3%
Industrials 8.3% 9.5%
Consumer Staples 5.3% 3.8%
Energy 3.5% 5.2%
Utilities 2.2% 0.3%
Real Estate 1.9% 1.1%
Materials 1.7% 2.4%

A snapshot of Zoya's AAOIFI ratings on November 19, 2026. Index weights are the stock holdings of the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust on November 18, 2026, rescaled to 100% with cash excluded; Compliant stocks keep their relative weights. Sectors follow GICS. One unrated stock is under 0.1% of weight; all shares are of total index weight and rounded. Shariah indexes apply their own rules, weighting and concentration limits, so their sector mix differs. For education only.

Financials shrink because banks, insurers and asset managers fail; the six that pass are mainly payments and financial data businesses, such as Visa. Communication Services nearly disappears because Alphabet, Meta and Netflix are Questionable. If the client accepts Questionable names, technology is 46.0% and communication services stays near its index weight.

You don't have to keep cap weights after screening. Single-stock and sector caps, or a different weighting method, can reduce concentration, with trade-offs in tracking error, turnover and taxes. Agree on the approach with your client.

Portfolio construction considerations

Beyond equity concentration, check these points with each client.

  • Benchmark: MSCI, S&P, Dow Jones and FTSE Russell publish Shariah indexes. Choose a benchmark that reflects the portfolio's restrictions. Against the S&P 500, a compliant portfolio will always show some tracking error, because it excludes part of the index.
  • Fixed income: sukuk differ from Treasuries in their issuers, structure and credit risk, so a sukuk fund isn't a direct substitute for a Treasury allocation. SPSK is the only dedicated US sukuk ETF at the time of writing; our sukuk guide explains how sukuk work.
  • Cash: "The default cash sweep program for many investment firms is often a bank sweep program," says an SEC investor bulletin, and that cash "generally earns interest." Check the client's sweep setting and see our halal money market alternatives.
  • Tax cost: selling a holding that turns non-compliant can realize a large capital gain, so weigh taxes when you set the divestment policy.
  • Overlap: Shariah ETFs that screen the same market hold many of the same large companies, so compare holdings before you combine two.
  • Fund liquidity: check assets, trading volume and spreads on newer funds before you size a position.

Agreeing on a Shariah investment policy

Agree on these points with your client before you invest and record them in the investment policy statement.

Policy checklist

  • Methodology: the screening methodology you'll apply (usually one you recommend), any scholar the client follows, or reliance on a fund's oversight.
  • Questionable holdings: include, exclude or decide case by case.
  • Extra exclusions: sectors to avoid beyond Shariah screening.
  • Non-compliant holdings: a divestment policy consistent with the client's Shariah guidance: whether a grace period is permitted, how long, and whether a ratio breach and a change in core business are treated the same way.
  • Unrated securities: whether a security with no current Shariah rating is blocked from purchase or manually reviewed.
  • Purification: the method (dividend-based, capital gains or AAOIFI's ownership-based approach) and who calculates and donates the amount.
  • Zakat: your role, the method and the client's zakat date.
  • Cash: how uninvested cash is held, including the sweep setting.
  • Retirement accounts: 401(k) menus, IRAs and plans with no compliant option.
  • Review and data: frequency, data source and off-cycle triggers.
  • Reporting: what the client receives, such as status changes and purification amounts.

Monitoring and maintaining compliance

A status can change when a company files new financials. Under a methodology that uses market value, such as AAOIFI's, it can also change when market value moves. Zoya updates each report in line with the company's reporting schedule, usually quarterly for US companies. How often you pull that data is a separate decision. A workable routine:

  1. Pre-trade check: pull the current status before every purchase.
  2. Periodic review: rescreen every holding on a schedule, such as after each earnings season.
  3. Event-driven reassessment: recheck a holding after earnings or a deal that changes its business.
  4. Remediation: apply the agreed policy, calculate any purification and record the decision.

A fund that tracks a Shariah index changes its holdings at the index's scheduled reviews. MSCI, for example, reviews its Islamic indexes in February, May, August and November. Between reviews, a stock's status can change as the company reports, so a holding can fail your screen while it is still in the index. Index buffers also keep some companies in an index after a ratio passes the limit. Your client's divestment policy decides how long you keep a holding that fails.

When a holding turns non-compliant

Zoya's help article describes two common approaches. Selling right away is the most conservative. The Shariah boards of various Islamic funds and index providers allow a grace period instead, often one or two financial periods, and sell if the holding still fails afterward. In either case, the usual guidance is to purify the dividends or gains earned while the holding was non-compliant.

Supporting clients with purification and zakat

Zakat and purification are separate obligations. Purification removes the prohibited share of investment income, while zakat applies to the wealth itself once a year. Your role can be to explain the methods, supply the data, calculate amounts under a method the client agreed in writing or refer complex cases to a scholar.

Purification

Most US Shariah fund issuers publish a per-share purification figure or a calculator, including SP Funds, Wahed, Manzil and Azzad, and leave the donation to the investor. Check each fund's practice so the same income isn't purified twice. SP Funds says its sukuk ETF, SPSK, does not require purification.

For individual stocks, the common method works from dividends:

Purification amount = dividends received × (impermissible income ÷ total income)

Hypothetical example: a client holds 1,000 shares of Company A, which pays $1.20 a share and earns 2% of its total income from interest. The client receives $1,200 in dividends and gives $24 to charity.

AAOIFI ties purification to ownership instead. Whoever holds the shares at the end of the company's financial period purifies its non-compliant income per share, whether or not it paid a dividend. Zoya's purification ratio is designed to be multiplied by dividends received. A client following AAOIFI's ownership-based method needs a per-share figure instead, which Zoya provides to firms in its data files.

A third method also purifies part of the capital gain on sale. Zoya's Shariah advisors recommend purifying both dividends and capital gains. Our stock purification guide covers each method.

Zakat

Scholars separate shares held for trading from shares held for the long term. Under International Islamic Fiqh Academy resolutions from 1988 and 2001, shares held for trading owe 2.5% of market value once a lunar year passes. Long-term holders pay on their share of each company's zakatable assets, such as cash, trade goods and debts owed to it. AAOIFI's zakat standard, Shariah Standard 35, takes the same approach.

Hypothetical example: a client holds a $200,000 stock portfolio, and their wealth is above the nisab (the minimum threshold for zakat) for a full lunar year.

  • Held for trading: $200,000 × 2.5% = $5,000.
  • Held for the long term: when company figures aren't available, one scholar-approved approach uses 30% of market value to approximate each company's current assets, as Zoya's help article explains. $200,000 × 30% × 2.5% = $1,500.

Zoya's zakat calculator runs this for stocks and funds.

A worked case study

Omar and Layla are hypothetical clients in their mid-40s, with moderate risk tolerance, a long-term growth goal and a fossil fuel exclusion. They hold $850,000.

Account Value Issue What you could do
Taxable brokerage $450,000 Conventional S&P 500 index fund Move to a certified Shariah fund that also meets the fossil fuel exclusion, if one exists, or a direct-indexed sleeve; manage the move around tax lots and unrealized gains
Omar's 401(k) $250,000 Conventional index and target-date funds Screen each fund; look for a Shariah option or a self-directed brokerage window
Inherited shares $100,000 A conventional bank, which fails the business screen Ask how their scholar treats the holding and its dividends; inherited shares usually take their value at the date of death as their basis, so a sale may realize little gain
Cash $50,000 Interest-paying bank sweep Change the sweep setting or use a halal money market alternative

Shariah screening alone won't remove fossil fuels: 80% of the S&P 500's energy weight was Compliant in Zoya's S&P 500 analysis above. A direct-indexed sleeve lets you add that exclusion on top. Omar and Layla's policy follows Zoya's ratings, excludes Questionable holdings, allows a one-quarter grace period and purifies dividends and capital gains.

A holding turns non-compliant

Eight months later, a large Compliant holding in the sleeve reports quarterly results. New borrowing lifts its debt to 34% of market value, above the 30% limit, and it turns Non-Compliant.

  1. Detect: your post-earnings data pull flags the change.
  2. Check the cause: note which screen failed and by how much.
  3. Apply the policy: the grace period starts. If the next filing still fails, the policy calls for a sale, with lots chosen to manage tax.
  4. Purify: track dividends and gains from the date of the change under the agreed method.
  5. Document: record the report date, data source, decision and purification amount.

How Zoya supports advisory firms

Zoya screens 60,000+ stocks and funds globally under the guidance of its Shariah advisors. Advisory firms, asset managers and financial institutions license its data to review existing holdings, build Shariah-compliant model portfolios, run direct-indexed sleeves and monitor compliance, within the investment process they already have.

The data

  • Security-level screening: each stock's Shariah status, business and financial screen results, and the underlying financial ratios.
  • Your investment universe: screening for the benchmarks, markets or security lists you choose, such as the S&P 500, MSCI ACWI or the Russell 2000.
  • Your methodology: screening under the widely used published methodologies, or custom criteria your Shariah advisors set.
  • Purification data: purification ratios and per-share amounts for each stock, to support whichever purification method your clients follow.
  • Updates: statuses refresh as companies report, so you can catch changes between scheduled reviews.

Delivery

  • Data files: recurring files built around your universe, methodology, fields and schedule, with no technical integration needed.
  • The Zoya API: for portfolio systems, research tools and client portals.
  • Custom work: bespoke methodologies, data requirements and service-level agreements.

All delivery options are licensed under a commercial data agreement.

If your firm is adding Shariah-compliant portfolios or improving an existing screening process, talk to our business team about your universe, methodology and delivery format.

Frequently asked questions

How do you structure a Shariah-compliant investment portfolio?

Start from a written policy the client agrees to: the screening methodology, how to treat Questionable stocks and any extra exclusions. Then fill each asset class. Equities can come from certified Shariah funds, screened stocks or a direct-indexed sleeve. Sukuk funds can provide fixed income exposure, though their risk and return differ from conventional bonds, and cash needs an alternative to an interest-paying sweep. Screen what the client already owns, then check each trade and rescreen holdings on a schedule.

Is there a halal version of the S&P 500?

Yes. S&P Dow Jones Indices publishes Shariah versions of the S&P 500, and SPUS tracks one of them. Under AAOIFI as Zoya applies it, 54% of the S&P 500's weight was Compliant on November 19, 2026, 20% Questionable and 26% Non-Compliant. A Shariah S&P 500 fund covers US large caps only, and its methodology may differ from the one you've agreed with your client.

Are ETFs halal?

It depends on the ETF. A Shariah-certified ETF follows a Shariah index or board, so the fund screens its holdings for you. A conventional ETF usually holds companies that fail the screens, such as banks. For a conventional fund, the Zoya app shows each holding's status for US ETFs and mutual funds, which helps when you review a 401(k) menu.

How do you vet stocks for Shariah compliance?

Check two screens. The business screen requires a permissible core business and impermissible income under 5% of revenue. The financial screen caps interest-bearing debt and interest-bearing assets, at 30% of market value under AAOIFI. Recheck after each filing, because statuses change. Screening data such as the Zoya API returns these results stock by stock.

Are there halal bonds in the US?

Conventional bonds pay interest, so Shariah-compliant portfolios use sukuk for fixed income exposure, though their risk and return differ from conventional bonds. In the US, SPSK is the only dedicated sukuk ETF at the time of writing. Shariah fixed income mutual funds include the Amana Participation Fund and the Azzad Wise Capital Fund. Our sukuk guide explains how they work.

Is a 401(k) or Roth IRA halal?

The answer depends on what the account holds. Check whether each fund on a 401(k) menu is Shariah-certified, and for conventional funds, the status of their holdings. If no fund fits, ask whether the plan offers a self-directed brokerage window. An IRA, including a Roth IRA, lets the client hold Shariah-compliant funds or stocks directly. Our guide Is my 401(k) plan halal? covers the options.

How do you calculate zakat on shares?

Under International Islamic Fiqh Academy resolutions, it depends on why the client holds the shares. Shares held for trading owe 2.5% of market value each lunar year. Long-term holdings owe 2.5% of the client's share of each company's zakatable assets, such as cash, receivables and inventory. When those figures are unavailable, one scholar-approved approach uses 30% of market value as a proxy.